‘Til Death Do Us Part

NOTE: I started this account four days after our 46th Wedding Anniversary on December 18, 2023. Myra died five days later. It sat in my draft folder for a year and I post it now on the 1st anniversary of Myra’s death for the sake of documentation and as an account of our Parkinson’s journey.

Myra’s grave decorated for Christmas 2024

On Tuesday, December 18, 2023, my wife, Myra, and I celebrated our 46th Wedding Anniversary. I use “celebrate” loosely since she was in bed all day, and I was addressing Christmas cards. You see, Myra was at the end of her 30+ year battle with early onset Parkinson’s Disease. We always knew that a time would come when she would succumb to the degenerative brain disease that impacts motor functions.

Still, she had several other symptoms, which we were not expecting with the initial diagnosis. She was spared the common symptom of tremors but had stiffness, slowness of movement, and uneven and unstable gait…sometimes resulting in falls. In fact, complications from falls are a leading cause of death in the disease process. She had several trips to the hospital for falls, resulting in lacerations, a fractured nose, and a concussion. Our friend and physician once said that Parkinson’s patients seem to fall in slow motion, which was true of Myra. Once, while she was still ambulatory, I left her for a bit only to find her after a tumble at the bottom of the basement stairs. Amazingly, her only injury was a hyper-extended finger. 

A walk on the Big River Crossing of the Mississippi River in Memphis.

She also developed orthostatic hypotension, a medical condition that results in a drop in blood pressure when standing up. This condition led to occasional fainting episodes. While generally controlled by medication and compression stockings, it was never totally mitigated and resulted in her first significant loss of independence: driving. Additionally, the condition made her more uncomfortable holding her infant grandchildren for fear of fainting while they were in her arms. 

A candid photo of Myra after being told by the neurologist that her driving days were over.

Another problem in advanced PD is swallowing difficulties, resulting in choking or aspiration. A weak cough prevents clearing aspirated liquids/food and can lead to pneumonia.  Pneumonia is a more common cause of death among people with PD than the general population. While Myra struggled with some aspiration of liquids, we, fortunately, had only one serious choking incident in which a large piece of beef obstructed her airway. I was able to remove it, avoiding a horrific death experience. 

But the hallucinations, the imagining of children playing outside or sitting in the bedroom, were an unexpected and disconcerting part of the journey. While the sightings were primarily non-threatening, they were so prevalent that she often didn’t even inform me of the apparitions’ frequency. Usually, they were our own daughters as children, who appeared at night in bed with her. When two of our daughters traveled from Texas for a surprise visit, she was genuinely uncertain when they appeared at the door and asked, “Are they real?” Another time, I was in a neighboring community when I received a cell call from one of the women attending a Bible study that Myra was leading in our home that night. When Myra took the phone, she told me a woman was dancing in the backyard and igniting the grass on fire with a torch. She was assured by the women at the house it was not real. I arrived home after the Bible study, but a few women remained with Myra. After they left, she confided that a “man” had been standing in the corner of the room all evening.

In the final years, we began dealing with dementia. Myra began to think there were “three Chucks: Chuck the husband, Chuck the pastor, and Chuck the photographer.” She would often talk about one of the other Chucks in my presence. We were driving back from visiting our children in Texas one late night. I pointed out an airliner that was on course to transit the moon. I commented that I would have liked to capture it if we had not been on the turnpike. Her response was, “Chuck likes to get those pictures.” Another time, as I left to take care of a ministry responsibility, she asked the caregiver, “Which Chuck was that?” One night, as I got her ready for bed, Myra looked at me and said, “I haven’t seen you for six months. I’m glad you’re back.” I’m unsure which Chuck had taken care of her during the preceding months…but I am pretty sure it was me.

Over time, there was a growing loss of recognition of her family. It was only occasional, or Myra covered it well (which I think she did), but by August of 2022, it was more apparent. Two of our daughters and families were in town, and when we returned from a day at the Iowa State Fair, Myra implored her caregiver, “Don’t leave me with those people.”

It was hard to see her grapple with the confusion that set in. She was uncertain where she lived for years, thinking it was an institution rather than our home. She would ask how long she had lived in “this place,” who was in charge of it, and how many others lived there. She was very concerned about our marital status and was uncomfortable sharing a bed with me if we were not married. I put our marriage license in a frame so she would know we were “legally and morally upright.” She repeatedly asked if I had a brother, having previously known I only had four older sisters. I finally asked her if another man who looked like me cared for her. Myra replied, “Yes.”

God provided a wonderful an incredibly knowlegable and caring neurologist, Dr. Lynn Struck, who treated Myra for decades. Additionally, a group of volunteers from our church stayed with her Sunday morning while I had church services and other occasions when I needed to be engaged in evening ministry activities. When we came to a point that Myra could not be alone, we contracted a paid service and excellent caregiver, Janet Webb, who came in for 20 hours a week, giving me additional time to engage in ministry outside the home. Finally, home hospice care was a timely resource in Myra’s last year and a half of life, bringing in a nurse, massage therapist, and a bathing aide several times a week, as well as making available supplies as Myra’s condition worsened.

Janet Webb, Home Sweet Home Care and Services owner, was an invaluable help for almost two years.

I had made a commitment to care for Myra at home. Thus, I was genuinely grateful that I could fulfill my pledge to her. After staying up all night and monitoring her condition, I dozed off between 5 and 6 a.m. on December 27, 2023. I awakened to find Myra had passed peacefully by my side.

There is no way to fully prepare for that transition of one’s spouse from the mortal to the immortal. Having lost her over time, our family often spoke of the grief we had already experienced in not having Myra as she had been. Even though she was still present, she was not the creative and fun grandmother to her grandchildren as she had been to her daughters. She could not be the gifted Bible teacher to children and women as she had been even as late as her early 50s. We lost our dreams of retiring together and traveling to see family and the sights we always longed to behold.

But that final “loss” of her presence has been different. The aloneness is palpable. Even though a day may be filled with friends or family, there is always a sense of something missing. I remember walking into the funeral home with my mother as she went for the first viewing of my dad after 62 years of marriage. Though she wanted to view him alone, one sister and I insisted that we accompany our 85-year-old mother. As she stood there, weeping at my dad’s casket, she said, “I feel like a part of me has been ripped out.”

I get that now.

When God brought the first man and woman together, the biblical idea was that they became one flesh (Genesis 2:24). Jesus reiterated that idea when he said regarding a husband and wife, “So they are no longer two, but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let no man separate” (Matthew 19:6). God’s ideal point of breaking the one-flesh union is “til death do us part.”

My consolation is that I know I will see Myra again. Her faith in Jesus Christ as her Lord and Savior guaranteed her eternal life even before she breathed her last breath. John 5:24 says, “Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life.” That hope sustains me, my children, and all who loved Myra.

How I Met Your Mother (Without the Bar and Barney) – My Eulogy at Myra’s Funeral

Featured

The first time I saw Myra, I was sitting in the Jones Hall dining room at Memphis State University with friends, including her then-current boyfriend. Barry and I were a part of Young Life Leadership, a para-church organization devoted to introducing adolescents to Jesus Christ and helping them grow in their faith. Interestingly, Barry had piqued a curiosity in Myra to know more about Christ. But, that particular day, she stormed up to the table and gave her a piece of her mind about something he had done that made her mad. She left and he laughed it off…but that was the beginning of the end for Barry. However, I didn’t know that.

A few months later, I began to see her at my home church. I later learned that a young adult member of the church and Myra’s co-worker, Lisa Woods Cannon, had been fielding some spiritual questions that Myra had. Lisa got to a point where she said, “You need to talk to my pastor.” So, Myra came one Sunday morning and told Herb Hodges that she would like to visit with him. He told her to come back for the evening service and she did. However, that night a missionary spoke, and she was bored to tears. She said if he had spoken in the morning service she would never have returned. The irony is that a few years later she had a passion for teaching GAs, a girls’ mission organization, and she made three mission trips to Venezuela.

Nevertheless, she made an appointment to meet Herb. Although she had gone to church as a child and early adolescent, she never knew what it was to have a personal and growing relationship with Christ. Myra came week after week with new questions that she had from reading assignments Herb had given her from God’s word.  

As a result of those meetings with Herb, she professed her faith in Jesus as he Lord and Savior. He explained that she should be baptized in obedience to Christ’s command to give a public response or an outward symbol of her new inward commitment. He suggested, what better time could there be than the upcoming Easter Sunday morning to announce to the church her intent to be baptized and also give her testimony of coming to faith in Christ. She didn’t know that the testimony component was not the regular practice in our church when one walked the aisle…so she just did it. At the end of the service, she stood at the front of the church and a long line of members welcomed her into the church family. I wanted to make a connection with her by mentioning the mutual friendship we had with Barry. Fortunately, the Lord thwarted that comment because when I took her hand, I lost my prepared speech. Instead, I stammered out something like “I’m Chuck Spindler and I have a friend who is a friend of yours.” I walked on, thinking “stupid, stupid, stupid.” I even told my sister, Mary how foolish I felt in that encounter. However, it was just peculiar enough of a church pickup line to generate some curiosity later, for she asked Lisa, “Who is Chuck Fenton?” 

Myra did not immediately merge into the young adult (collegiate) group. She often sat by herself in our large sanctuary. But one Sunday night I got the courage to invite her to join our group for pizza after church. She accepted, and we began to hang out in group settings over the spring and summer months of 1976. We developed a strong friendship without the pressure of romance for the next six months. We prayed together, we talked about what we were learning through our personal Bible studies, and we memorized scripture together. And when we started dating in August those habits continued into our marriage on December 18, 1977. 

Myra was involved in the collegiate Navigator ministry with a strong emphasis on discipleship, reproducing believers after the pattern of 2 Timothy 2:2. She took seriously the call to entrust to faithful people what she had learned, so they, in turn, could teach others also. Whether it was the milk of the foundational, elemental Bible truths in children’s Sunday School or the solid food and the word of righteousness for the maturing woman of faith, her goal was as the writer of Hebrews says, to train them to discern good and evil. (5:12-14). 

Along the way, many of you have been her disciples, you might not have known to put that word to it, but you were. Just as Paul said “Be imitators of me, just as I also am of Christ” you have discerned in her those winsome ways of Christ that were demonstrated in her lifestyle and teaching and by which you find yourself imitating Myra’s words and actions. 

Psalm 90:10 says, “The years of our life are seventy, or even by reason of strength eighty; yet their span is but toil and trouble; they are soon gone, and we fly away.” Now this verse does not say God caps our life at the age of 70 or 80. Nor is it a promise that we will live that long. However, it does speak of the toil and trouble that we endure in life and that all too soon it is finished, and we fly away or die. Coincidentally, Myra lived exactly to the age of seventy and struggled with Parkinson’s disease for over 30 years, initially with just weakness on her right side but finally with the inability to verbally communicate, ambulate, and personally take care of her own needs. 

My sister, Mary, wrote of the losses that we all experienced over the year of her disease:  

“I’ve missed the talks alone with Myra that Parkinson’s Disease (PD) robbed. I hate that PD robbed Mackie’s grandchildren of the fullness of her creativity, quiet humor, and open expressions of delight in children. I’m sorry that Bethany [our Associate Pastor’s wife] couldn’t draw on the years of experience as a pastor’s wife: with all its ups and downs, disappointments, joys, misunderstandings, and spiritual breakthroughs. I hate that Chuck will not have a couple’s trip to the beach or the Grand Canyon. But oh, Myra is restored. She’s living with sight after faith. She’s absent – but present with the Lord. Thank you, Jesus: for my sister, for her sharing, for the love and acceptance and welcome she always showed me. And thank you that she introduced Denny [her husband] to Culvers.” 

POSTSCRIPT: Myra and I celebrated our 46th wedding anniversary on December 18. It was a non-event for at that time she was bedridden and had begun the process of active dying. refusing food and water. Early on December 27, I awakened after dozing off for about an hour to discover she had made the transition from mortal to immortal, from the temporal to the eternal.

While there is and will continue to be sadness in her absence, there is joy in the assurance we know she is whole and healed and in the presence of her Lord and Savior. We have the hope that we will see her again and our grandson, Silas [see My Birthday Present]. We grieve with hope!

For we know that if the earthly tent which is our house is torn down, we have a building from God, a house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens. For indeed in this house we groan, longing to be clothed with our dwelling from heaven, inasmuch as we, having put it on, will not be found naked. For indeed while we are in this tent, we groan, being burdened, because we do not want to be unclothed but to be clothed, so that what is mortal will be swallowed up by life.Now He who prepared us for this very purpose is God, who gave to us the Spirit as a pledge. Therefore, being always of good courage, and knowing that while we are at home in the body we are absent from the Lord— for we walk by faith, not by sight— we are of good courage, I say, and prefer rather to be absent from the body and to be at home with the Lord. (2 Corinthians 5:1-8, NASB)

Beloved, now we are children of God, and it has not appeared as yet what we will be. We know that when He appears, we will be like Him, because we will see Him just as He is. And everyone who has this hope fixed on Him purifies himself, just as He is pure. (1 John 3:2-3, NASB)

It’s Not that Time of Year Without… Remembering Dennis

As Advent begins tomorrow, I was setting up my personal crèche to use as an object lesson with the children during the worship service. Starting out with only the animals and an empty manger, I plan to add figurines each week until the Christ child is added on Christmas morning.

Advent 2.jpg

As I unpacked the nativity set, I thought of Dennis. He was a youth in my first church, who gave us the nativity set nearly 30 years ago. I think of him every Christmas as I break the crèche out of the box.

Dennis had experienced a hard life by the time he came to our church at the invitation of classmates. Both of his parents had died, and he was being raised by an older sister. Short, ruddy, quiet but quick witted, Dennis quickly endeared himself to us.  After a summer youth trip to Branson in which he stabbed another youth in the leg (the truth dennisof how that happened never came out), we had a “come to Jesus talk” and he actually did come to Jesus, that is.

Along with the other youth, Dennis spent a lot of time in our home. He was included in a number of our celebrations, with him supplying the giant cookie from the Great American Cookies store where he worked in the mall. One Christmas he gave us the Fontanini nativity set and he added other figurines over the next few years.dennis-2

I moved to another church staff position in Memphis and then to Iowa, and we lost touch. I tried tracking him down through the internet and eventually found a newspaper article, touting his success in producing organic vegetables and selling them at farmers markets in Memphis. I actually emailed the business he operated, but never heard from him.

Today, my thoughts about this youth, who by now would be about 50, caused me to do a Facebook search again, and I found him. However, I quickly discovered the posts were not by him but about him. Shortly, I reached a post that expressed sorrow for his sudden death on February 15, 2012. The news was like a punch in the gut. I quickly messaged another of the “youth” from that church, who coincidentally just “friended” me on Facebook. He shared that Dennis had a heart attack and died…and “sorry, thought someone told you.”  I know that I could not have prevented his death by staying in touch, but I wish that Dennis had known how I remembered his kindness every time I’ve unpacked the nativity set he gave us so long ago.

nativity-setTomorrow is the first Sunday of Advent. We will be lighting the Hope candle, as it represents the hope the people of God had for the long awaited Messiah. Foreshadowed through the curse of the serpent in Genesis 3, promised in the Abrahamic covenant (Genesis 15), and prophesied in many other Old Testament passages (Micah 5:2-3, Numbers 24:17, Isaiah 9:6), God’s people were hopeful. They longed for good news to the afflicted, comfort for the brokenhearted, the proclamation of liberty to the captives, and freedom for the imprisoned (Isaiah 61:1). And they were certain that God would fulfill His promises as He had time and time, again.

With every Advent season and every communion we are reminded of the hope that we have in Christ Jesus. The Messiah came to fulfill all that God had promised and there are still promises to be fulfilled. As a lamb led to slaughter, who did not protest (Isaiah 53:7), Jesus willingly took upon Himself my sin and suffered my death, enabling me to have eternal life with Him. He continues to give hope to all who know Him as He is coming again to receive us unto Himself. And for that, I am eternally grateful for the light of hope shines upon me.

And so, it’s not that time of the year without remembering Dennis. But knowing that Dennis and I had that “come to Jesus” talk gives me the hope that I will see him again one day…the very HOPE that causes us to celebrate the first Sunday of Advent tomorrow.

Weekly Photo Challenge: Connection

Quote

I didn’t think long about the most appropriate pictures for this challenge. Two weeks ago today (August 24) my mother graduated from this earthly plain to the heavenly realm. Over the next week we gathered in three locations – three significant places of residence: Creston (IA), Benton (AR) and Memphis (TN) – holding two memorial services and the graveside service.

We gathered as a family almost 10 years ago at the First Baptist Church, Benton for my father’s memorial service. Mom stood on the bottom step in purple in this photo.2005.10Almost 10 years later I updated that picture, connected by event (memorial service), place (church steps) and family (the growing and older connected progeny of Charlie and Grace) in grief and celebration that our matriarch is with the Lord, my father, a granddaughter, my grandson (who I didn’t meet in this life), and many other loved ones who have preceded us.

Family at BentonLooking at the photo with all the smiling faces, you might think we had just attended a wedding. Rest assured, we are grieving, but with hope!

13 But we do not want you to be uninformed, brethren, about those who are asleep, so that you will not grieve as do the rest who have no hope. 14 For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so God will bring with Him those who have fallen asleep in Jesus. 15 For this we say to you by the word of the Lord, that we who are alive and remain until the coming of the Lord, will not precede those who have fallen asleep. 16 For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. 17 Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we shall always be with the Lord. 18 Therefore comfort one another with these words. (1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 NASB*)

And who couldn’t smile at the sense of humor of a 95 year old woman’s final wish to have this picture and caption on the back of her memorial folder!

IMGP8887

In response to The Daily Post’s weekly photo challenge: “Connected.”

*New American Standard Bible (NASB) Copyright © 1960, 1962, 1963, 1968, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1975, 1977, 1995 by The Lockman Foundation

To Our Beloved Bunny

Kids at Mom's bedWhile my four sisters, my wife and I have been physically present with my mother in hospice care for the last week and a half, other family members have sought by other means to be present to express their love and appreciation of their beloved grandmother and great-grandmother (aka Bunny). Spanning the distance of the country by phone and Facetime, they have expressed that love through words of remembrance, singing, piano playing and the words “I love you, Bunny!” Below, I reblog my daughter’s post from yesterday, one of those fitting tributes, that I was able to share with my mother today.

To Our Beloved Bunny

My grandmother is in hospice care…and while she is still with us, though I’m certain she is certain of my love for her…I won’t wait to write it down. I need to do it now.

IMG_2742

I can’t stop thinking of my last hospital stay, exactly one month ago, for the birth our of twins. With that stay, came the promise of finality: of pregnancy and of delivering babies. The end was in site: the end of tests and dr’s visits and apprehension. And that hospital stay culminated in life. For months, I was so giddy when I thought about coming home with life. Leaving with LIFE, 2 lives. The thought of it made me cry.

In so many ways, her stay in the hospital now is the same, final and culminating in LIFE. The end of this life on Earth, means life in Heaven for her. And at 35, I can barely wrap my mind around the idea of being excited about that. But for her…for my Bunny, our Grace, it means seeing her mom and dad, and brothers and sisters, and her beloved, our Pop. It means holding my sister’s baby boy, Silas, before any of us do. It means greeting our cousin Amy again with a kiss and tears. It means seeing the face of God. And sitting here thinking about THAT, about seeing Jesus…that makes me giddy for her, even in my heartbreak over my impending separation from her.

So how do I honor this woman, who for my entire life has meant the world to me; who has prayed unceasingly for all of us, remaining lucid for her 94 years, sharing griefs and triumphs, stealing giggles on porch swings over slightly inappropriate stories, fingers still gliding effortlessly across piano keys? For this woman who is a picture of godliness and purpose, I will honor her with my words…and I think that’s how she’d want me to honor her.

Bunny and me

Two things about my grandmother have shaped me and helped me to become who I am.

The first is music. 

When I was five, I remember telling Bunny a story using the keys of her piano to differentiate my characters. Then she taught me about the symphony, sitting on the floor listening to Peter and the Wolf…hearing story through music for the first time. And years later, it was Bunny who encouraged my first piano lessons. And finally in high school, when I was still practicing piano at my dad’s church, Bunny bought me my own piano, perhaps the most amazing gift I’ve ever been given. The gift of song. And because of her blood that courses through me and her influence, I feel God’s glory no more acutely than when I am wrapped up in the beauty of making music.

The second is faith.

When I was little my mother taught us how to study God’s word. I will always look back and praise God for a mom who was disciplined in her teaching of us. Without her, I would have no idea that the Bible is indeed living and active and sharper than any two edged sword. But it was Bunny, who also helped shaped the love of Bible study into my mom. I love legacies. I love tracing my faith back to faithful men and women. I am so grateful.

I loved watching my mom and dad wake up every morning and pray together…I saw that in my grandparents, too. I hope our children will remember our prayer times, too.

Bunny and Georgie

It’s impossible to wrap up my grandmother in a silly blog post, just as it’s impossible to catch the memory of a dream the night before with our words. It all falls short. To list all of my memories seems trite. But they are a part of me. She is a part of me.

Not everyone gets the pleasure of having a family that they are wild about. I do. And at the helm is Bunny.

Bunny, you mean the world to me. I love you more than words could ever say. Your purpose in my life…has been inexplicable.

Originally posted on http://www.itsallbananas.wordpress.com: To Our Beloved Bunny

Some additional pictures of Mom, me, Anna and my granddaughter, Charlie.